This week I did some beta-reading for my friend Karen Coles, who, as KE Coles, wrote the highly successful young adult Mesmeris trilogy, the dark and compelling story of a sinister religious cult. When Karen told me she was going to write an historical next, I immediately offered to read it for her if she thought it might help and I was delighted when she asked me to look at the opening chapters.
|
What I didn't know before I started it was that it would turn out to be pure gothic. Bliss! I've been a fan of the gothic romance ever since I was a teenager lapping up Victoria Holt's wonderful books. |
The chapters I beta-read were filled with atmosphere (Karen is superb at creating atmosphere, as you'll know if you've read Mesmeris) and rich description, plus a generous sprinkling of menace and mystery. My feedback praised all these elements, then went on to make a couple of comments about how I thought she could make her writing even better.
She was pleased with my feedback and agreed with my comments. Phew! One happy writer and one happy beta-reader.
If only it could always be like that!
A couple of years ago, I was asked to beta-read for a friend, who made a point of insisting several times, "Be honest." So I was. There isn't much point being a beta-reader if you aren't. I gave feedback on what I considered his writing's strengths to be, followed by some queries and suggestions.
Let's just say he wasn't pleased. He clearly didn't want a beta-reader - he just wanted someone to admire his work. He should have asked his mum to read it.
Have you ever a beta-reader for another writer? Did it go well? Share your beta-reader stories here!
|
Make A Comment
Comments (4)